
R.D.
It's good to see the story before lords of the rings. It is a good movie with a lot of funny stuff and emotional scenes where you almost cry.
Cool fighting scenes and good animation made the movie look brilliant. The introduction and return of the main villain of the movie is also excellent. Yet there are a lot of bad or missing things, or even things that aren't yet understood. One thing, as example, is why the dwarfs and Gandalf didn't go and check the ruins of the castle , where the dark was coming from ?? Next thing is : what are those dark things and where did those spiders came from ?!!!
Now I am coming to the worst parts, for me. Gollum.... I still remember him as Smeargle. I don't know why, but I can't stand him being called Gollum... Next to the fact about Smeargles name, I hoped that Smeargles
past would be explained better in this movie somehow. I searched on wiki's and found some information, yet major questions remain: Why is he alone? Why is he talking to himself? Why is he 'misformed'?
The ending is the worst thing I ever saw. The end would be better if for instance: If there was a fight and someone was going to hit someone with a sword. You would get a shot of that person coming to you about to hit you with, a strike, and then the screen turns black and it says: To be continued.... That would have been a better ending then now. Now you get to see a mountain, looking like a paradise. You think yourself: "Wow, nice... It is beautiful... Now it's almost ending, they are almost there. They'll probably get into major problems or fights. It could also be that the journey is still long but then it will be continued on a fight as a cliff hangar...". But no. Now it ends like that, and an emotional scene with Thorin stating he was wrong to Bilbo. Damn that's just lame. Such a beautiful screen makes me feel like that's the ending. Well actually it looks like an ending and feels like a continue... While actually it needs to look like a continue cause the damn journey isn't finished yet!
Saruman is still a dick as I remember. Makes the scene between Gandalf and Galadriel even funnier. It was the funniest scene ever! The last two also shared a romantic scene together which was very touching. The first emotional scene is when Bilbo is writting his memoires and starts about this journey. The last scene in which Thorin states he was wrong about Bilbo was also very touching!
8/10
The Veggi Lady
Although the film itself was brilliant, I found the end unsatisfying and very disappointing. There lacked a real cliffhanger.
The settings were again overwhelmingly beautiful and fairylike.
I'm especially a big fan of the Elves: so mysterious and graceful, Galadriel (played by Cate Blanchett) just seemed to float. The actress was very well cast for the role and plays it truly sublime. All actors played their roles with gusto.
It seemed to me that Gollum did have two personalities: a submissive, sweet 'male' side and a very dominant and malicious "feminine" side. I wonder: how and why did those personalities emerge ?
The fighting, "tricks" and special effects were fantastic!
But that end, that messed up the film for me, so I give it a ...............................................................
7/10
Don't forget to check out my other blog
